This is Halifax Pride week. Coincidentally, it's the 25th anniversary of the Americans with Disabilities Act. I've long admired the speed with which the LGBTQ+ community has reached its goals. I'm jealous.
It's interesting to consider the mirrored trajectory of these superficially similar social movements in Canada and the US:
- In the US, same-sex marriage just became universally available last month
- In Canada, it's been around since July 20, 2005
- In the US, the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has not been ratified, even though it is clearly modeled after the ADA
- In Canada, the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has been ratified but not implemented
- In the US, Josh Cassidy, a Canadian, set the world's record in the wheelchair division of the Boston Marathon
- In Canada, there is no wheelchair division in the Scotiabank Blue Nose Marathon
- In Canada, the federal government uses a shredding facility that pays people with intellectual disabilities $1.15/hour
- In the US, President Obama signed an executive order mandating minimum wage for any federal contract, including sheltered workshops
I'm not enough of a social scientist to make complete sense of these incongruities, but this paragraph from the Canadian Index of Wellbeing webpage hints at something:
From (a) cornerstone principle of shared destiny and collective action, a number of core consensus values informed the development of the CIW: fairness, diversity, equity, inclusion, health, safety, economic security, democracy, and sustainability.and here are 9 core American Values identified by Robin Williams (not that one) in 1970 that hint at something else:
- Equal Opportunity
- Achievement and Success
- Material Comfort
- Activity and Work
- Practicality and Efficiency
- Progress
- Science
- Democracy and Enterprise
- Freedom
Two competing ideals seem to be at work:
You can see how the Canadian values might favor Pride and American values might favor Rights.
Please share your thoughts by commenting.
- Independence vs Inclusion
- Equal opportunity vs Equal Outcome
You can see how the Canadian values might favor Pride and American values might favor Rights.
Please share your thoughts by commenting.
No comments:
Post a Comment