Welcome

...to the website of the James McGregor Stewart Society. We want to change the outlook for people confronting barriers. Please share this site with friends. Your contributions, comments and criticisms will add enthusiasm and vitality.
Please participate by subscribing!
Click here (opens a new window)
Statement of Purpose......... Take Action!......... Become a Member......... Contact
Showing posts with label Constituency Offices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Constituency Offices. Show all posts

June 12, 2019

Old News Redux

PC MLA ordered to comply with accessibility rules by June 20


Dear Ms. Paon,

How is it that a duly elected representative could be so ignorant of democracy? A team effort made accessibility a requirement in 2013 and you're flouting the law.  While you've been busy claiming reimbursement for your illegal constituency office, voters with disabilities have been treated with contempt. Your ludicrous defense:

  •  "Paon said no one has ever told her or her staff they could not get into the building because of the gravel space. We've received absolutely no complaints, we have a high percentage of seniors in my constituency and my brother is a paraplegic, so I'm very cognizant of accessibility issues." - Jean LaRoche, CBC

is so tiresome and condescending that it is almost beneath a response.

  • The biggest Catch-22 for wheelchair users is that they are often prevented from having a voice simply because they can't get in to complain.  "I can't hear you, shouting out there in the parking lot."  Maybe that explains why you have discriminated in employment as well.
  • And of course your paraplegic brother makes you a world-class authority on disability.  When your brother is a paraplegic, you should know better.

Time to get with the program.  People with disabilities make excellent employees.  They are loyal voters.  Not facts a politician can afford to ignore.

Gus Reed

April 26, 2015

Constituency Office follow-up

Parker Donham asked for a follow-up on the accessibility requirement for constituency offices.  Under the new rules, 31 of 54 offices (3 MLAs have 2 offices) are presently accessible.

6 have been granted exemptions for not having visible AND audible alarms, though I don't understand why they're too cheap to buy one.  Here's one for seventy-five bucks.

Geoff MacLellan of Glace Bay was re-elected and moved his office, which is still not completely accessible.  His lease runs out June 30.

17 have been grandfathered under the old (nonexistent) rules and have evidently been too busy to read the handwriting on the ramp.  These are (a couple in flux):

Baillie, JamieCumberland SouthRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016PC
Casey, KarenColchester NorthRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Churchill, ZachYarmouthRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Colwell, KeithPreston-DartmouthRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Corbett, FrankCape Breton CentreRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016NDP
Glavine, LeoKings WestRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
MacDonald, MaureenHalifax NeedhamRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016NDP
MacLeod, AlfieSydney River-Mira-LouisbourgRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016PC
MacMaster, AllanInvernessRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016PC
Orrell, EddieNorthside-WestmountRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016PC
Porter, ChuckHants WestRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016PC
Regan, KellyBedfordRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Samson, Michel PCape Breton-RichmondRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Whalen, DianaClayton Park WestRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Wilson, DaveSackville-CobequidRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016NDP
Younger, AndrewDartmouth EastRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016L
Zann, LenoreTruro-Bible Hill-Millbrook-Salmon RiverRe-elected MLA, due October 2016Not required until Oct 2016NDP

PC 5
Liberal  8
NDP 4

Not to make too much of the $89,234.90 each of these gets paid, I'd just say disabled taxpayers aren't getting a lot for their $1,517,010.30.  It's only democracy, not something vital like Mr. Leahy's tax credit.

I looked at a couple of places in Google Street View.  The Premier's place in Middleton looks pretty thin on the accessible parking requirements, but I'm holding fire until I can get to Middleton with a television crew.   

My suspicious nature got the better of me when I looked at Randy Delorey's Antigonish office in Street View.  Remembering his office is on the 2nd floor and doubting the 2 story building has an elevator, I asked accessibility advocate Anne Camozzi to have a look.  She reported completely:

They have some issues with signage which I pointed out - mainly there are two entrances to the bldg. one says Randy Delorey and there's a flight of stairs.  If you did not know, there is no signage to indicate a second entrance further from Main St. also marked Randy Delorey with a push button door and elevator.  I pointed out the need for signage at the first entrance.
Once off the elevator there are two fire doors to get through to get to his office. I needed help with those doors. His assistant was very obliging.  They had changed all their doorknobs to levers
The main door to his office is narrow but got my big power chair through just barely. It is def not a 36" door. Inside OK.  Its a very tight turn in.  The accessible washroom is not in his office but in the nearby Dept. of Environment office on the same floor.  There's a door I could not open to get to the Dept. of Environment area where the washroom is located but by knocking on the door someone can come from Environment and opened it. I pointed out this needed to be signed.  Others more able bodied in a chair could probably open the doors.
Did not have time to try the washroom and was worried about my power chair and tight spaces.His assistant seemed keen to know what was working and not working and came downstairs to more fully understand the signage.

So there you have it.  Two thirds Accessible, One third dragging their feet (knuckles).

Gus Reed

January 24, 2015

Ontario



MORE THAN VOTING BOOTHS: ACCESSIBILITY OF ELECTORAL CAMPAIGNS FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES IN ONTARIO is a long article from Ontario about the rather sorry state of accessibility at campaign offices.

The page, on the website of the 

ACCESSIBILITY FOR ONTARIANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (AODA) Note: This is NOT a Government run Site!!.

reminds everyone of the ineffectiveness of the Ontario Legislation:

The AODA Clock is Ticking
There are 9 years, 49 weeks, 1 day till a fully Accessible Ontario! Will you be compliant?

This timetable, seemingly based on the end of the world scenario, when asteroid Apophis collides with Earth in 2029, promises four years of accessibility before everyone is blown to smithereens.  

In the lengthy article, no reference is made to Nova Scotia's pioneering requirement that MLA offices be accessible (since 2013, mind you).

Nor do those Ford voters seem to grasp that not being able to get into such an office means a person with a wheelchair could never ever be employed there.  

Of course bodily functions are not a consideration in Ontario, but here in Nova Scotia we treasure our right to pee in constituency offices, where accessible washrooms are mandated.

If I lived in Ontario (shoot me!), the glacial pace of accessibility reform  would drive me crazy.  It's demeaning, counterproductive and just plain cowardly.

As we lead up to our own accessibility legislation in Nova Scotia, let's remind ourselves that the best example is right here at home.  MLA constituency offices must be accessible.

Gus Reed

ps for the not-faint-of-heart, here's more on the failure of The AODA:

PREMIER WYNNE AND ECONOMIC DEVELOP MINISTER DUGUID RESPOND TO AODA ALLIANCES DETAIL PROPOSALS TO GET ONTARIO BACK ON SCHEDULE FOR FULL DISABILITY ACCESSIBILITY BY 2025

and it just gets worse (sorry for the ads):

July 27, 2014

Videos

It's worth remembering that a year ago we were in the middle of an effort to make MLA constituency offices accessible.  The analogy to what was accomplished in this short film is unmistakable.


Although our approach was less dramatic, it was equally effective.  We are well into the next phase; legislation to enshrine equal opportunity for all Nova Scotians  We don't want to squander the opportunity.

For your amusement, here is a wry look at similar legislation in the UK


And the PG-13 sequel

October 15, 2013

How we spent our summer vacation




With special  thanks to:
Graham Steele and Gordie Gosse for leadership
Parker Donham and Kelly McKenna for persistence
Stewart, McKelvey for support
Nova Scotia for doing the right thing

August 14, 2013

A foot in the door

Last night the news had a segment on the latest exoskeleton from Ekso Technologies.  There was the technology-smitten reporter, the paraplegic person who took a step, the outtake from Elysium, the sympathetic manufacturer promising much lower prices than the current $110,000 per.  People without disabilities still don't get it.

A far more significant development occurred today in Nova Scotia.  The internal operations arm of the legislature, the House of Assembly Management Commission, made a rule requiring  that elected representatives have barrier-free offices in their home districts.  It passed unanimously.

This simple regulation marks a sea change in approach for the provincial government:

  • People with disabilities are acknowledged to have the same rights as others
  • Written rules, rather than promises, are the solution
  • All parties agree on the principle, the problem and the solution
  • The initiative came from the community of Nova Scotians with disabilities
Let's hope that the lesson is not lost and that it sets a precedent.  In order for Nova Scotians with disabilities to become full citizens, they need equal access to all parts of their world.  The UN Convention on the rights of Persons with Disabilities finally has some promise:

Article 9 - Accessibility1. To enable persons with disabilities to live independently and participate fully in all aspects of life, States Parties shall take appropriate measures to ensure to persons with disabilities access, on an equal basis with others, to the physical environment, to transportation, to information and communications, including information and communications technologies and systems, and to other facilities and services open or provided to the public, both in urban and in rural areas. These measures, which shall include the identification and elimination of obstacles and barriers to accessibility, shall apply to, inter alia:
  1. Buildings, roads, transportation and other indoor and outdoor facilities, including schools, housing, medical facilities and workplaces;
  1. Information, communications and other services, including electronic services and emergency services.
We salute the good work of the HAMC and the leadership of Speaker Gosse!

May 28, 2013

From Today's Contrarian

Reposted with kind permission of contrarian.ca.  The meeting on Thursday at 1 in Province House is open to the public.  Can we have some wheelchairs present please?


A committee meeting at Province House this week has the potential to correct a logstanding injustice in the way Nova Scotia is governed.

At the behest of the James McGregor Stewart Society, a disability rights organization, the House of Assembly Management Commission will consider requiring constituency offices to be fully accessible before MLAs can claim reimbursement of office expenses.

You might expect this to go without saying in 2013, but it doesn’t. Many MLAs’ offices are only partly, if at all, accessible. They may have a level entry or a satisfactory wheelchair ramp, but lack a paved parking lot or an accessible washroom. They may have a wide enough door to admit a wheelchair, but no automatic door opener to let wheelchair users come and go unassisted.

People with unrestricted mobility sometimes miss the significance of that last distinction. Wheelchairs users value their autonomy as much as anyone else. They want to participate without having to ask for help.

The House Management Commission doesn’t have to guess about what constitutes an accessible office. The standards are clearly set forth in Section C of the Nova Scotia Building Code, which all new commercial construction must meet.

It’s not clear that any of the constituency offices now in use fully comply with this standard. This effectively bars Nova Scotia’s 28,000 wheelchair users from full participation in the political process. It puts constituency office jobs beyond reach of applicants with disabilities.

MLAs know this is unacceptable. The gentle explanation for why it wasn’t fixed a generation ago is inertia. In many parts of the province, it’s hard to find good office space. Many MLAs enjoy a close relationship with their landlords, which they aren’t anxious to disturb. No one likes the hassle of moving to new quarters.

That’s why the summer of 2013 offers a unique opportunity to correct this injustice. The election that’s expected this fall will produce an unusually large crop of new MLAs, all of whom will be seeking office space. The Commission could require any new constituency offices to comply with Section C in order to qualify for reimbursement. It could establish a firm timetable—certainly no more than the five-year term of a typical commercial lease—by which existing constituency offices must be brought into compliance. The first election after 2013 could serve as a final deadline for existing offices.

Leasehold improvements are a standard feature of office leases. The landlord carries out the work, builds the cost into the rent, and ends up with a more desirable, barrier-free property at the termination of the lease.

Fixing this problem will undoubtedly cause some inconvenience for MLAs. In a letter to the Commission, the society put that burden in perspective:
The challenges MLAs will face meeting this requirement are real, but they must be weighed against the perpetuation of second-class citizenship for 28,000 Nova Scotians. One is a matter of inconvenience; the other a human right.
Speaker Gordie Gosse chairs the Management Commission, whose members include MLAs Frank Corbett, Becky Kent, Pam Birdsall, Moe Smith, Michel Samson, Chris d’Entremont, Andrew Younger, and House of Assembly Chief Clerk Neil Ferguson. The Commission meets Thursday at 1 p.m. in the Red Chamber.

If it fails to act before the upcoming election, we’ll have to find a stronger word than “inertia.”