Welcome

...to the website of the James McGregor Stewart Society. We want to change the outlook for people confronting barriers. Please share this site with friends. Your contributions, comments and criticisms will add enthusiasm and vitality.
Please participate by subscribing!
Click here (opens a new window)
Statement of Purpose......... Take Action!......... Become a Member......... Contact

September 27, 2015

How to Lie with Statistics

On Thursday, HalifaxExaminer published this announcement of a Government meeting:

Crosswalk safety advisory committee (10am, City Hall) — there’s been a welcome decline in the number of pedestrians struck:
I don't know if Tim is just pulling our leg, but nothing could be further from the truth. As I have said before on this subject, the police's insistence on viewing the complex world one variable at a time can lead to false conclusions and, most importantly, neglects important information. A simple example:

Rather than looking year-by-year, here is a graph of the complete 3 1/2 years, showing that 2015 has barely nudged off the moving average of 17.1 incidents per month (The lowest moving average, 14.7, occurred in August, 2013):

This can be confirmed by averaging the data by month and comparing it to the first seven months of 2015:
The downward trend of 2015 seems to occur in the first half of every year.

Better yet is a summary by season, which does provide a clue as to what's happening:

You don't suppose that pedestrian collisions are connected to lousy snow clearing? Sounds pretty far fetched......

I promise you that the number of collisions will soon rebound to the 15-20 range, peaking in the winter months.  As a wheelchair user, I take this personally because I'm not very agile in avoiding hurtling autos.  

The chart of Vehicle-Pedestrian Collisions is entirely inconclusive as to any trend and further demonstrates HRM Police’s confusion of ‘counting’ with ‘analysis’. The stubborn reliance on considering one variable at a time means that important questions go unanswered.
  • Which intersections have accidents during peak commuter times?
  • Are there intersections that are dangerous for under 25-year-olds on weekends?
  • Do lighting conditions make a difference?
  • How about the pattern of paint?

Intersections are complex, and the problem will persist until the complexities are accounted for.  Arithmetic just isn”t enough.

No comments: